Why PE Transformations Fail—and How to Ensure They Succeed

Private equity (PE) firms are at the forefront of driving transformative change, often injecting capital into businesses to accelerate technology adoption, integrate AI, or restructure operations for maximum value creation. Yet, despite their expertise and resources, nearly 70% of transformation projects—many backed by PE—fail to deliver their intended returns. Drawing on my extensive experience in business value creation, project management, AI, and transformation, I’ve identified the root causes of these failures and developed a robust framework to help PE firms and their portfolio companies succeed in high-stakes transformations.

Success is the only option - Private equity thrives on unlocking value quickly, often within a 3-7 year exit horizon. Transformations in PE portfolio companies—whether implementing AI-driven analytics, modernising legacy systems, or streamlining operations— all critical to boosting EBITDA and securing lucrative exits. However, the pressure to deliver rapid results can lead to missteps. A failed transformation not only erodes financial returns but also risks reputational damage for both the PE firm and the portfolio company. Understanding why these initiatives fail is the first step to ensuring they succeed.

In my view, two primary culprits undermine PE-led transformations: misaligned stakeholder expectations and inadequate change management. Misalignment often occurs when PE firms prioritise short-term financial metrics, such as cost reduction or revenue spikes, while portfolio company leadership focuses on long-term innovation or cultural integration. For example, a PE firm might push a tech portfolio company to adopt AI for supply chain optimisation to boost valuation, only to find operational teams unprepared, leading to delays and cost overruns. Similarly, inadequate change management—failing to address the human element—can breed resistance. Employees may fear job losses from automation or struggle with new technologies, stalling progress and eroding value.

Another subtle but critical factor is the complexity of integrating new technologies under tight timelines. PE-driven transformations often involve daring goals, such as deploying AI platforms or digital overhauls, but without proper planning, these initiatives can overwhelm teams and infrastructure, leading to costly setbacks.

From my time designing and implementing PE transformations, two lessons stand out. First, iterative feedback loops are essential for alignment. In one PE-backed tech firm, we implemented biweekly stakeholder syncs, bringing together investors, C-suite leaders, and operational teams to align on the technology integration goals. This prevented missteps and kept the project on track for a successful exit. Second, AI-driven insights can transform decision-making. Predictive analytics tools, for instance, flagged potential talent shortages in a portfolio company’s digital transformation, allowing us to address the issue before it delayed the project. Combining disciplined project management with cutting-edge technology is non-negotiable in PE’s high-pressure environment.

To maximise returns and avoid transformation pitfalls, PE firms and portfolio companies can adopt this five-step framework:

1. Align Stakeholder Goals Early: Convene workshops to reconcile PE exit strategies with portfolio company priorities. Use frameworks like OKRs (Objectives and Key Results) to define shared metrics, such as EBITDA growth or tech-driven revenue uplift.
2. Invest in Robust Change Management: Develop tailored training programs to ease adoption of tech, AI or new processes. Communicate benefits clearly to employees—e.g., how automation enhances efficiency rather than replaces jobs—to build buy-in.
3. Leverage AI Strategically: Use AI tools for everything from due diligence to post-acquisition integration. For example, machine learning can optimise supply chains or predict market shifts, directly impacting valuation.
4. Iterate Relentlessly: Implement short feedback cycles (e.g., weekly sprints) to adapt to challenges like integration hurdles or market changes, ensuring agility in PE’s fast-paced timelines.
5. Track Value Creation Rigorously: Define clear KPIs—revenue growth, cost savings, customer retention—and monitor them using dashboards to provide real-time insights for investors and management.

PE-driven transformations are high-risk, high-reward endeavours. The pressure to deliver rapid value creation in a competitive, tech-driven market makes alignment, adaptability, and strategic technology use critical. By addressing stakeholder misalignment, prioritising change management, and leveraging AI, PE firms can turn portfolio companies into success stories. Whether scaling a tech startup or restructuring a legacy business, the right approach delivers measurable results and maximises returns. This isn’t just about avoiding failure—it’s about redefining what success looks like in PE transformations. 

What’s your experience with PE-driven transformations? Have you faced challenges in aligning stakeholders or adopting new technologies? Share your insights  or connect with me to explore how we can drive value together.

If you would like to know more about our services and experience around PE value creation through transformation, please reach out by clicking the button below